Forrest Arehart began his career in public accounting back in 1963. As his practice grew, he founded Arehart Associates in 1976, building it one client relationship at a time. When Forrest retired in 2001, he left behind more than a business — he left behind a firm deeply respected throughout the Shenandoah Valley, and a way of doing things that still guides us today.
A Legacy Built on Relationships
Numbers matter, but they're never the whole story — behind every balance sheet is a family, a dream, a business someone has poured themselves into. That's why, since our founding, we've made it a priority to actually know our clients, not just their accounts. It's why so many of the people we work with have been with us for years, even decades, and why our team feels less like outside advisors and more like an extension of your own.
We've grown over the years, but that founding belief hasn't changed. When you work with Arehart Associates, you're not just getting a firm with a long, respected history in the Valley — you're getting a team that still shows up, remembers your name, and genuinely cares how you're doing.
We believe accounting is a people business.
That "way of doing things" comes down to one simple idea:
Our Team
Jan S. Hoover, CPA
Partner
Jan has been part of the Arehart Associates story for over 40 years. She graduated from the University of Virginia in 1979 with a Bachelor of Science in Commerce, concentrating in accounting, and joined the firm in 1984 — bringing decades of public accounting experience and a deep familiarity with the clients and community we serve. Outside of the office, Jan is the definition of a family person — with 10 grandchildren, she's always finding time to be there for them, especially cheering them on at the ball field.
Amber B. McLain, CPA
Partner
Amber earned her Bachelor of Business Administration with a concentration in accounting from Bridgewater College in 2004 and has been with Arehart Associates since 2006. Her experience and steady, client-first approach make her a trusted partner to the businesses and individuals she works with. When she's not at the office, Amber is usually spending time with her husband and two daughters. She enjoys family outings, and a little retail therapy whenever she gets the chance. Life outside the office keeps her on her toes!
Bobbie Sheffer, CPA
Bobbie earned her B.B.A. from Mary Baldwin College in 2000 and joined Arehart Associates in 2009, where she has built lasting relationships with clients across the Valley. Outside the office, Bobbie is a woman of many talents — she loves to line dance, has a real artsy streak, and plays in the Stonewall Brigade Band.
Leslie Wood, CPA
Leslie earned her B.B.A. from Radford University in 1985 and joined the firm in 2016, bringing a wealth of accounting knowledge and a dedication to getting things right for every client. When she's not at the office, Leslie loves relaxing and spending time with family. She loves showing them around the local area and attending local farmers’ markets and local art events. She also enjoys nature walks and hiking throughout the area.
Emily Rutledge, CPA
Emily graduated from James Madison University in 2020 with a Master's in Accounting and joined Arehart Associates the same year — bringing fresh energy and a strong foundation to the team. Outside of work, Emily enjoys traveling, staying active, spending time outdoors, and making memories with her family and loved ones.
Tyler Seamster, CPA
Tyler earned his B.B.A. from James Madison University in 2022 and joined Arehart Associates the same year, continuing the firm's tradition of thorough, client-focused service. Outside the office, Tyler is always on the hunt for his next great find! He runs his own eBay store and enjoys spending his free time thrifting and hitting up yard sales.
Faith Howerton
Staff Accountant
Faith earned her B.B.A. from James Madison University in 2026 and joined Arehart Associates later that same year. When she’s not at the office, she enjoys hiking and spending time outdoors with her husband. She also has a passion for wildlife photography and loves capturing photos of the critters she encounters along the way.
Josie Anderson
Staff Accountant
Josie earned her Master’s in Accounting from Western Governors University in 2025 and joined Arehart Associates in 2026, bringing a background in industry accounting and a practical understanding of business accounting and financial operations. Outside of the office, Josie is a crochet pattern designer and enjoys expressing her creativity through various fiber arts.
Jamey Chandler
Payroll Manager
Jamey earned her B.B.A. from Mary Baldwin College in 2009 and has been with Arehart Associates since 2004, where she keeps our clients' payroll running smoothly and accurately, every time. Outside of work, Jamey and her husband keep busy with their three kids, all of whom play sports — you can usually find her at a basketball court or ball field cheering them on.
Melissa Shover
Office Manager
Melissa keeps things running smoothly here at Arehart Associates as our Office Manager. She greets our clients with a smile and friendly conversation. Outside the office, she's Mom or Mamaw — always spending time with her family, which includes 6 grandchildren.
Who We Work With
Over the years, we've had the privilege of working with all kinds of clients across the Shenandoah Valley, including:
Nonprofits and community organizations
Real estate professionals
Transportation
Manufacturing
Professional services
Health professionals
Condo owners associations
Retail
Contractors and tradespeople
Farms and agriculture
Small and family-owned businesses
Individuals, families, estates, and trusts
Don't see your industry listed? That's okay. Give us a call and let's talk about what you need.
Credentials & Recognition
Peer Reviewed
CPA firms that perform audits go through peer review every three years, an independent evaluation of their work by another CPA firm. Our most recent peer review, completed in 2024, received a rating of pass. Read the report
LINKS
Recognized Locally
Voted a Waynesboro Valley Favorite in 2024, 2025, and 2026.
Memberships
American Institute of CPAs (AICPA), Virginia Society of CPAs (VSCPA)
Come see why our clients stay for decades
Give us a call at 540-949-0124. We'd love to get to know you.